Skip to content
FREE Shipping when you spend $50 or more CODE: GIVETHANKS
FREE Shipping when you spend $50 or more CODE: GIVETHANKS

Holiday Pantry

  • Tiny Tender Yoder Popcorn
    $5.50

    Tiny Tender Yoder Popcorn

    Yoder Popcorn

    Yoder Popcorn is one our favorite popcorns to make at home! Bryson's family is from Indiana and they've all grown up eating this delicious treat. ...

    View full details
    $5.50
  • Coffee Crunch Bar
    Sold out
    $7.50

    Coffee Crunch Bar

    Olive and Sinclair

    The fudgy backbone of our 67% Ghana chocolate with hints of red stone fruit and brown butter mixes and matches perfectly when studded with freshly...

    View full details
    $7.50
    Sold out
  • Sea Salt Chocolate Bar
    Sold out
    $7.50

    Sea Salt Chocolate Bar

    Olive and Sinclair

    Speckled with flaked sea salt, it begins with a clean salinity, lending itself to the occasional satisfying crunch and burst of flavor, awakening ...

    View full details
    $7.50
    Sold out
  • Yoder Popcorn Caramel Corn
    from $3.00

    Yoder Popcorn Caramel Corn

    Yoder Popcorn

    Not too sweet, delicately crunchy, tiny popcorns. It's really some of the best, simple, caramel corn we've tried.  Packaged in small serving bags, ...

    View full details
    from $3.00
  • 67% Cacao Chocolate Bar
    $7.50

    67% Cacao Chocolate Bar

    Olive and Sinclair

    This chocolate is bold, brown, & fudgy, introduced by red stone fruit, brown butter and sorghum molasses. It's Susan's favorite because it's n...

    View full details
    $7.50
  • Super Fine Popcorn Salt
    Sold out
    $3.50

    Super Fine Popcorn Salt

    Yoder Popcorn

    If you're a popcorn lover, then you absolutely need super fine salt in your pantry. The fine salt crystals cling to the nooks and crannies of popc...

    View full details
    $3.50
    Sold out
  • Cinnamon Chili Bar
    Sold out
    $7.50

    Cinnamon Chili Bar

    Olive and Sinclair

    This is a fantastic "hot" chocolate bar. Notes of delicious chocolate, cinnamon and a spicy afterbite. We loved it melted into a latte or made into...

    View full details
    $7.50
    Sold out
  • Chocolate-Chocolate Hot Chocolate Mix
    $9.99

    Chocolate-Chocolate Hot Chocolate Mix

    Silly Cow Farms

    Fair Trade Certified means that the ingredients in this Sillycow Farms product are produced according to rigorous social, environmental, and econo...

    View full details
    $9.99
  • Chocolate Peppermint Twist Hot Chocolate Mix
    $9.99

    Chocolate Peppermint Twist Hot Chocolate Mix

    Silly Cow Farms

    Fair Trade Certified means that the ingredients in this Sillycow Farms product are produced according to rigorous social, environmental, and econo...

    View full details
    $9.99
  • Marshmallow Swirl Hot Chocolate Mix
    $9.99

    Marshmallow Swirl Hot Chocolate Mix

    Silly Cow Farms

    Fair Trade Certified means that the ingredients in this Silly Cow Farms product are produced according to rigorous social, environmental, and econ...

    View full details
    $9.99
  • Premium Red Yoder Popcorn
    $5.50

    Premium Red Yoder Popcorn

    Yoder Popcorn

    Yoder Popcorn is one our favorite popcorns to make at home! Bryson's family is from Indiana and they've all grown up eating this delicious treat. ...

    View full details
    $5.50